The following is a chat log from our #SSX IRC Channel from 27th May 2006.
(@Judd-MGT) I think it probably safer to say that WoW creates guilds that can only support multiples of 40.. Anyone who isn't on page with that other 40 will tend to be left out in the cold or felt unwelcome
(@Judd-MGT) It is brilliant from the stand point of Blizzard, becuase it pretty much ensures that you have chaos in the ranks of any guild, no matter their influence..
(@Judd-MGT) Or how structured they are.
(@Judd-MGT) Which means people will continue to play as they look for that perfect group, and it creates almost an addiction, just like it takes only 5 to win the last minute of a basketball game, but people will continue to try to achieve it.. Lots of people will try.. :)
—› quit: (farenheit451) (~451@ool-18b8a082.dyn.optonline.net) (Quit: Beware of programmers who carry screwdrivers.))
(@QuantumDelta) most guilds
(@Judd-MGT) How do we as a group of much larger than 40 survive such a design?
(@QuantumDelta) - raiding guilds,
(@QuantumDelta) recruit 55 ish _people_
(@QuantumDelta) of specific class balance
(@QuantumDelta) and maintain that, and that alone, if people become inactive they're replaced
(@QuantumDelta) keeping themselves balanced and everyone at 90% ish attendance
(@QuantumDelta) as for us
(@Judd-MGT) Yep.. which for the game = success.
(@QuantumDelta) I'm surprised we've survived as long as we have really
(@Judd-MGT) Which is hard because we don't operate that way, and yet you have to do the raid instances.
(@Judd-MGT) So you end up building such a network internally. If not intentionally. It does evolve over time.
(@QuantumDelta) that's the thing
(@QuantumDelta) it's not really built that way with us
(@QuantumDelta) We do 3 40man raid instances
(@Judd-MGT) I don't think it is that way Directly.. But I do sense a culture if you will of the raiders. Just from watching posts, and convos here.
(@QuantumDelta) the first one, molten core, can be attended by anyone, basically, it's a 'gearing ground', this is a trash instance that the guilds more equipped and switched on members can 20man
(@QuantumDelta) with ease^
(@QuantumDelta) we take 10 of those members, and 30 people who need stuff there so that everyone who doesn't get to go to the other instances can go to mc
(@QuantumDelta) the geared, but less experienced people go to bwl
(@QuantumDelta) where you have to learn to work a bit if you want the raid to succeed (read; can't just rely on 10 people and spam one button for 3 hours)
(@QuantumDelta) most of the guild is at this stage
(@Judd-MGT) But there it is plain as day.. There is a seperation between those we can, and those who can't.. It sucks.. But it is there.
(@QuantumDelta) and finally; ahn'quiraj - where the people like ava and I are even relatively under geared and unexperienced
(@QuantumDelta) but it's not malicious segregation
(@Judd-MGT) Yeah it is a tiered existence
(@Judd-MGT) No.. I am sorry, I don't mean to make it sound malicious
(@QuantumDelta) in MC or BWL I can almost solo heal ava
(@Judd-MGT) It is an inherent part of the games design..
(@Judd-MGT) You can
(@QuantumDelta) he will trust me he'll rely on me
(@Judd-MGT) 't help but be cornered or peg'd... :)
(@QuantumDelta) he'd probably try to duo the instance if I asked him to :P
(@QuantumDelta) but
(@QuantumDelta) in AQ I _need_ to be able to depend on the other healers
(@QuantumDelta) so it's just a question of who's experienced and geared
(@Judd-MGT) Yep, which means you aren't gonna be sitting there with people who don't know what they are doing or prepared
(@QuantumDelta) that experience is filtered into the MC peeps
(@Judd-MGT) Yeah I know, but it still creates what can be seen, and while it isn't meant to be bad, or anything like that, it will inherently make people feel unwelcome.
(@Judd-MGT) It is ... human nature.. :)
(@Judd-MGT) And.. worst of all... There is no way to fix it..
(@QuantumDelta) well.......
(@Judd-MGT) It is like in EVE, at some point you do become what we all avoid if you want your corp to be big or influential
(@QuantumDelta) we took a couple of the normally MC candidates into BWL the other week
(@QuantumDelta) they spent the entire 5 hour run alive for probably....30 minutes
(@QuantumDelta) they must've died well over 18 times
(@QuantumDelta) compared to my 1... :|
(@QuantumDelta) the game just doesn't let us take them elsewhere
(@Judd-MGT) Yeah.. I know... Again, it isn't a slight on them, it is the reality of the game design.
(@Judd-MGT) But if you were in their shoes, it would be ... disheartening..
(@QuantumDelta) well
(@Judd-MGT) And it was when you were there in their shoes.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) it's kinda a cheat for me ;\
(@Judd-MGT) at your level now, yes.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) since I walked into MC in gear that healed as well as I do now (I just have more HP now)
(@Judd-MGT) hahahah.. yeah..
(@QuantumDelta) well thing is...
(@QuantumDelta) I had all the best blue stuff in the game
(@QuantumDelta) most of it 'priest' items (better than pally in itemisation)
(@QuantumDelta) so in all these months of raiding my gear has only really gone up in the amount of hp and armour i have
(@QuantumDelta) not my 'important to the raid' stats :P
(@QuantumDelta) rogues and warriors need high stamina though which is a lot more harsh
(@QuantumDelta) i've never felt the problems they have, i just know of them on a raid leader level :\
—› join: (BlueFlames) (~BlueFlame@c-68-34-213-78.hsd1.tn.comcast.net)
—› mode: (ChanServ) sets mode (+o BlueFlames)
(@Judd-MGT) Well you have always been a natural born leader..
(@Judd-MGT) hey BF..
(@Judd-MGT) You are also used to grinding through to getting what you want..
(@Judd-MGT) As you said in your post, you worked through it with no one really to help you.
(@BlueFlames) Greetings. I prefer 'conqueror' to 'leader', it should be noted.
(@Judd-MGT) Greeting, Loser..
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@QuantumDelta) lol
(@Judd-MGT) I will add that to my auto send for you.. :)
(@Judd-MGT) it starts with L.. :)
(@Judd-MGT) anyways.. How's school life BF..
(@BlueFlames) It's summer, so I'd have to call one of those dumb shmucks taking summer classes. ;-)
(@Judd-MGT) QD you are part of the mere 10% of people in this guild or any guild that will play the game regardless of what the difficulty is..
(@Judd-MGT) 50% give up if they run into any difficulty that seems hard.
(@Judd-MGT) The rest will only work through IF someone holds their hands.
(@Judd-MGT) ahhh.. thought you were in charge of a dorm or something
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@Judd-MGT) Glad to be home then BF?
(@QuantumDelta) Heh KJ
(@QuantumDelta) If that were true we wouldn't be as far as we are now :p
(@QuantumDelta) Huhuran is _hard_
(@QuantumDelta) yet, this week, they've spent 7 hours just wiping on her
(@BlueFlames) Well, resident assistants go in a week early to open the buildings and stay a week late to close. It's the hall directors that are around for the whole year. I'm enjoying the break right now though. I'm finally getting caught up on a few weeks worth of sleep.
(@Judd-MGT) I think you are confusing what people would do with they are willing to do with friends around.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) hmm..true..
(@QuantumDelta) but i'm proud of 'em :\
(@Judd-MGT) They won't fight the battles unless you are sitting there with people you trust... which only proves my point.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) even if I was yelling at them cuz some of them were slacking
(@Judd-MGT) They are looking up to a core group of people.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) heh..humm
(@QuantumDelta) I have no idea what I can do to help all of them :\
(@QuantumDelta) especially people like Oz, who aren't even at the MC Level
(@Judd-MGT) You can't help all of them.. that is a fact of life.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) but that's painful and it feels like i'm failing them :\
(@Judd-MGT) I know.. It is frustrating, but it is like a giant trying to help an ant gather food.
(@QuantumDelta) :\
(@Judd-MGT) What we need are those who are like Oz who are only casual and non-raid specifics who will stand up and be leaders for the casual players
(@QuantumDelta) well...like I said in my post
(@Judd-MGT) But the hard part is once you start acting like a leader you get dragged up the skills/equip list until you are up with eeveryone else.. ;)
(@QuantumDelta) err
(@QuantumDelta) for the record
(@QuantumDelta) imo oz really isn't casual
(@QuantumDelta) he's quite hardcore, he's just a little bit ...confused, perhaps because he plays a hybrid
(@QuantumDelta) he has trouble managing it all atm
(@QuantumDelta) but he plays probably about 50% of the time I do and I play an unhealthy amount as it is
(@Judd-MGT) Some people do... Casual also is a definition for those that play their own way.. and not the way it takes to win
(@QuantumDelta) hmmm
(@Judd-MGT) Tis True QD.. you play too much.. :)
(@Judd-MGT) just kidding
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@QuantumDelta) I really do
(@QuantumDelta) 189 days played on my main
(@QuantumDelta) 20 days played on my primary alt
(@QuantumDelta) 2 other olds -.-
(@QuantumDelta) alts**
(@Judd-MGT) look, you slackin' on your alts.. you haven't played enough
(@QuantumDelta) lol :P
(@QuantumDelta) just cuz going into the pre-mc instances (even for myself!) makes me want to gouge my own eyes out
(@QuantumDelta) that's the only reason I haven't played her much :P
(@Judd-MGT) Anyways.. People who play their own way no matter the advice or help they have been given, would be casual, becuase their goal is not to be overtly successful
(@Judd-MGT) Yeah, I know what you mean
(@QuantumDelta) point taken
(@QuantumDelta) still I don't mind if Oz goes PvP
(@QuantumDelta) I did :)
(@Judd-MGT) I have 4 chars at lvl 30.. and working on 3 others, just getting them to 30 feels liek a wash rinse repeat process
(@QuantumDelta) PvPs fun as long as it isn't turned into a grind for ranks
(@Judd-MGT) I follow th4e quest chains the same except for my druid
(@QuantumDelta) heh
(@Judd-MGT) He started in elf land, which has a different quest chain than when you start near stormwind
(@QuantumDelta) you're on mannoroth? with mag?
(@Judd-MGT) yeah
(@Judd-MGT) They don't complain about me much..
(@Judd-MGT) becuase I keep my head below the radar.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) no one complained about oz afaiknew :\
(@Judd-MGT) hahahaha. wasn't meant as a comparison.. ;)
(@QuantumDelta) ahh but it felt a good time to throw it in :p
(@Judd-MGT) good point.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) his post on the forums was the first i'd ever heard of negative commentary on him
(@Judd-MGT) Anyways... This just what i have seen from playing and watching..
(@Judd-MGT) An unintentional elitism (for lack of a better word) exists.. But it isn't what people say it is, or as bad as people portray it as...
(@QuantumDelta) ye
(@Judd-MGT) Experience in the game will invariably lead everyone to the same point, but sometimes when you are working towards it, it can feel ... different than everyone else.. :)
(@Judd-MGT) I don't have a single lvl 60, and I feel snubbed at times when in game.. becuase my questions don't relate to others
(@Judd-MGT) They are all prepping raids and what not, and here I am asking about the wetlands.. hahahahaha
(@QuantumDelta) lol
(@Judd-MGT) So there are times when my questions go unanswered.. :)
(@Judd-MGT) But I have learned not to take it personal, but others can and probably will.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) well it's true but it's happening a lot recently
(@Judd-MGT) more people have crossed the levels recently.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) to the point that two people who recently joined us (felt alienated by it and left) from another guild (the most successful on the server) -.-
(@Judd-MGT) Well, that begs the question, why did the leave the other guild? same reason?
(@Judd-MGT) :)_
(@QuantumDelta) Nah, they were forced out.
(@QuantumDelta) I swear to god
(@QuantumDelta) there is a carbon copy of Suzanne on outland
(@Judd-MGT) no way?
(@Judd-MGT) You think it might actually be her?
(@QuantumDelta) same attitude
(@QuantumDelta) same psychosis
(@QuantumDelta) same manipulative nature of guys
(@Judd-MGT) 8-)
(@QuantumDelta) it's not suz though
(@QuantumDelta) since she actually tried to associate with me before she realised she couldn't use me for power -.-
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@QuantumDelta) anyway
(@QuantumDelta) she destroyed their previous guild
(@QuantumDelta) out of ~30 bosses in the game
(@QuantumDelta) they had 14 server first kills
(@Judd-MGT) damn wow
(@QuantumDelta) a lot of their members applied for us cuz they wanted to chill out
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@QuantumDelta) but we're so full if we take on more people we're shafting the rest :I
(@QuantumDelta) everyone says "Oh I don't care about raids"
(@Judd-MGT) yeah particularly if you brought in that many experience and geared players.. it would be inevitable
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@QuantumDelta) but raiding is where 75% of the socialising it -.-
(@QuantumDelta) is*
(@Judd-MGT) well what else is there to do if you are level 60
(@Judd-MGT) you can PVP, but to get the gear to be good, you have to raid forit.
(@Judd-MGT) Inevitably it all builds to it
(@QuantumDelta) there's the 'trash instances' pvp world bosses (Raids) and instance raids :I
(@Judd-MGT) but they are all basically the same idea
(@QuantumDelta) well...
(@Judd-MGT) get a group of people and raid an area for goods.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) there's also reputation grinds for the casual players
(@QuantumDelta) There's a rep grind even no one in SSX has completed yet in winterspring for a super-rare mount
(@Judd-MGT) wow.. cool.. that is probably wihat I will be doing once I get there
(@Judd-MGT) But grinding like that will wear on even a casual gamer
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@QuantumDelta) it's a great q for casuals (if a little longwinded...)
(@QuantumDelta) because you can do a little bit every month and never 'miss out'
(@Judd-MGT) cool
(@QuantumDelta) There's another bunch of similar grinding quests in the new content at silithus
(@QuantumDelta) but the rewards are all inferior to gear i had before they were even patch notes..so not worth it for anyone in ssx eu
(@Judd-MGT) The reality is all the great gear can only be raided..
(@Judd-MGT) Atleast the volume of great gear
(@QuantumDelta) aye
(@Judd-MGT) So ... it is... inevitable
(@QuantumDelta) sigh :\
(@Judd-MGT) And thus for every gen of recruits that come in... we go throught he same cycle
(@Judd-MGT) Some will become raid experts, some will feel snubbed, some will just follow their friends whatever level they are at, and etc.. :)
(@QuantumDelta) well....
(@Judd-MGT) I think what may help to solve this problem is a lengthy announcement post about the state of the game and how it effects the players
(@QuantumDelta) AQ doesn't allow that :\
(@QuantumDelta) Heh true
(@Judd-MGT) If someone has a problem with something, point them to that first
(@QuantumDelta) I dunno how the guild is gonna react to the last 4 bosses of AQ40
(@QuantumDelta) If anyone isn't paying 100% attention for C'Thun (the last boss)
(@Judd-MGT) Maybe even have MS work with ya and do a FAQ and try to give answers for all the questions that normally crop up
(@QuantumDelta) They die
(@QuantumDelta) pretty much instantly
(@Judd-MGT) damn
(@QuantumDelta) Even paladins bubbling don't survive <3
(@Judd-MGT) damn that is harsh
(@QuantumDelta) considering our raids are normally carried by 10 people, fleshed out by another 20 and then have 10 wandering around randomly pressing buttons (or, it feels like it)
(@Judd-MGT) hahahaha.. end of raid.. :)
(@Judd-MGT) heheheh
(@Judd-MGT) People won't like having the reality of the game stated so plainly.
(@QuantumDelta) yea needless to say i've been prepping a big pep talk for him :P
(@Judd-MGT) But it needs to be said
(@Judd-MGT) And people need to understand who and how they are to request help
(@QuantumDelta) Cuz I do expect them to down him, even if not cleanly ;)
(@Judd-MGT) Maybe even something as simple as using our dkp site to provide a means ot request help
(@QuantumDelta) hmm
(@QuantumDelta) how so?
(@Judd-MGT) We could code in a request form
(@QuantumDelta) well....setting up events would be kinda nice
(@Judd-MGT) People request help via the form, a group of people get emailed the request, the request is handed down to players who are in positions to help with the request
(@QuantumDelta) We've also never been able to actually 'schedule' raids because of the large difference in the memberships quality of gear and experience
(@Judd-MGT) With a bit of coding trickery we could have it post tot he forums as well
(@Stracius) too... much... work
(@QuantumDelta) the moderators/classleaders/raidleaders are always left to the last minute to see who is online as to if there's even a raid on the night -.-
* @Stracius faints as his head explodes
(@SSX-MS) just skimmed through most of the writing, but i kinda like the idea of a request form.
* @QuantumDelta soothes Stracius, there there, things will be alright...
(@Judd-MGT) I wish WoW would allow us even limited access to the user information
(@QuantumDelta) heh :P
(@Stracius) isn't there a simpler solution? :P
(@Judd-MGT) This is a complex problem
(@QuantumDelta) a very large thermo nuclear device?
(@Stracius) like, oh, I dunno, people just asking questions, and .. oh, say... others answering them directly? :P
(@Judd-MGT) There are no simpler solutions
(@Judd-MGT) but guild chat is ignored, vent is not everyones cup of tea
(@Judd-MGT) and People don't always know who to direct questions to when they aren't answered
(@Stracius) raids run every night?
(@Judd-MGT) particularly if selected group of people are in raid
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@Stracius) ya know something funny
(@Stracius) I actually avoided raids when I could after I hit 60
(@Stracius) I felt like the ppl who weren't that high yet were getting neglected, so I tried to make up for it
(@QuantumDelta) good raids are the best thing :<
(@Stracius) sounds like you guys have similar problems
(@SSX-MS) most nights pretty much yea
(@QuantumDelta) heh
(@Stracius) but then again, I think I enjoyed the game the most when I was helping others *shrug*
(@QuantumDelta) well I've always stated that people leveling mains for the first time up shouldn't really expect help, even if only so that they can learn the game :P
(@QuantumDelta) honestly speaking I don't mind helping people if they're genuinely stuck
(@Judd-MGT) I would agree with that sentiment abotu mains
(@QuantumDelta) but I see a lot of ppl asking for easy escapes :\
(@Judd-MGT) But other people won't ... :)
(@Stracius) hmm. I'm kinda opposite that, really
(@Stracius) I help with the mains, but not so much the alts
(@Stracius) don't get me wrong
(@Stracius) I make them learn what they are doing in the process
(@Stracius) but I just didn't have the energy to do alts too
(@QuantumDelta) heh
(@QuantumDelta) I don't have the energy to do any anymore
(@Judd-MGT) There is a big difference between helping a main, and doing the work for them
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@QuantumDelta) _but_
(@Stracius) Having to learn by yourself might be the best way in the view of hard knocks
(@QuantumDelta) when I walk into any instance that's lower than sunken temple
(@Stracius) but it's frustrating
(@QuantumDelta) I instantly trivialise the entire thing for all of them.
(@QuantumDelta) Because I can solo those instances
(@QuantumDelta) so they may as well be AFK
(@Stracius) ah, well that's where being a druid came in handy :P
(@Stracius) I could keep them alive, but I couldn't kill stuff for them, lol
(@QuantumDelta) imma pally
(@Judd-MGT) with uber equipment now... :)
(@Stracius) something's wrong with that :P
(@QuantumDelta) i can heal and tank and dps at the same time on lower instances :\
(@QuantumDelta) okay..
(@QuantumDelta) I'm a pally with sulfuras the hand of ragnaros
(@QuantumDelta) and out dps probably about 70% of the warriors on my server -.-
(@Stracius) but then, i never really saw pallies with good eq, and it's been over a year
(@QuantumDelta) and can heal
(@QuantumDelta) and have plate :I
(@Judd-MGT) QD = bastard
(@Judd-MGT) hahahahha
(@Judd-MGT) Also means that PvP is probably boring for you as well QD
(@QuantumDelta) I'm weird about pvp :\
(@QuantumDelta) Dueling ppl honourably I normally either lose or Barely win
(@QuantumDelta) but if 2-5 people try to gank me i'll kill a few of them or all of them before i die
(@QuantumDelta) x_X
(@Judd-MGT) basically meaning you don't try your best on a 1v1
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@Judd-MGT) but that is okay
(@Judd-MGT) I am pretty sure you are of the personality not to bastardize people (gank the living hell out of them) even if you know you could
(@QuantumDelta) I don't touch horde unless they don't give me a choice, or gank people infront of me -.-
(@Judd-MGT) But force them to try to out power you (ie the more than one seituation) and you go into own their asses mode
(@Judd-MGT) yep
(@Judd-MGT) That sounds exactly like what I am talking about
(@Judd-MGT) :)
(@Judd-MGT) well I think I have said enough on the situation for now
(@Judd-MGT) Now it is time to let it sit and float, and gestate, and see what the outcome is.
(@QuantumDelta) I'd probably post the irc log but it wont fit in the post thingy
(@Judd-MGT) If we need to setup something let me know, I am game to try anything if you think it might help
(@SSX-MS) i can shove the irc log on a webpage later if ya'wanting =)
(@Judd-MGT) I am going to go ingame and see if I can level my pally to 30
(@Judd-MGT) at 25 righ tnow
(@Judd-MGT) probably a linked page is best
(@Judd-MGT) I hope I have atleast been somewhat helpful, and not another pain in the ass telling you what to do.. :)